Macy's Presents: The Edit- A curated mix of fashion and inspiration Check It Out
Free Shipping with $75 purchase + Free Store Pickup. Contiguous US. Exclusions
  • Natural Beauty, The Ingredients You Want Without The Extras You Dont
  • Out with The Bad, Parabens, Phthalates, Sulfates
  • 35 items in

    Eye Shadow Natural Beauty

    Narrow by Category

    • Filter
    • Sort By
    • All Items (35)
    • Free Pickup
    • Sort by
    • NEW! NUDESTIX 8-Pc. The Nude Beach Palette Set
      A $198.00 value
      Only $75.00
      Free shipping at $75
      Free Shipping & Returns with $75 Beauty Purchase
      Free shipping at $75 Free shipping at $75
      Free gift with purchase
      Free Makeup Gift w/ $45 Select Beauty Purchase
      Free gift with purchase Free gift with purchase
    • NEW! Tarte 3-Pc. Social Star Color Set
      A $40.00 value
      Only $29.00
      Free shipping at $75
      Free Shipping & Returns with $75 Beauty Purchase
      Free shipping at $75 Free shipping at $75
      Free gift with purchase
      Free Makeup Gift w/ $45 Select Beauty Purchase
      Free gift with purchase Free gift with purchase
    • Tarte 3-Pc. Tarteist PRO Remix Palette Set
      A $143.00 value
      Only $105.00
      Free shipping at $75
      Free Shipping & Returns with $75 Beauty Purchase
      Free shipping at $75 Free shipping at $75
      Free gift with purchase
      Free Makeup Gift w/ $45 Select Beauty Purchase
      Free gift with purchase Free gift with purchase
    • 3 colors
      NUDESTIX Nudies Matte Blush
      $32.00
      Free shipping at $75
      Free Shipping & Returns with $75 Beauty Purchase
      Free shipping at $75 Free shipping at $75
      Free gift with purchase
      Free Makeup Gift w/ $45 Select Beauty Purchase
      Free gift with purchase Free gift with purchase
      (4)
    • Tarte Tarteist Pro Remix Amazonian Clay Palette
      $49.00
      Free shipping at $75
      Free Shipping & Returns with $75 Beauty Purchase
      Free shipping at $75 Free shipping at $75
      Free gift with purchase
      Free Makeup Gift w/ $45 Select Beauty Purchase
      Free gift with purchase Free gift with purchase
      (1)
    • NEW! P/Y/T Beauty No BS Eyeshadow Palette
      $32.00
      Free shipping at $75
      Free Shipping & Returns with $75 Beauty Purchase
      Free shipping at $75 Free shipping at $75
      Bonus Offer with Purchase
      Tarte Prom Set $12 w/ select Prom purchases
      Bonus Offer with Purchase Bonus Offer with Purchase
    • 3 colors
      NUDESTIX Magnetic Nude Glimmers
      $28.00
      Free shipping at $75
      Free Shipping & Returns with $75 Beauty Purchase
      Free shipping at $75 Free shipping at $75
      Free gift with purchase
      Free Makeup Gift w/ $45 Select Beauty Purchase
      Free gift with purchase Free gift with purchase
      (2)
    • 2 colors
      Koh Gen Do Maifanshi Mineral Eye Shadow Palette
      $50.00
      Free shipping at $75
      Free Shipping & Returns with $75 Beauty Purchase
      Free shipping at $75 Free shipping at $75
    • 6 colors
      Beauty by POPSUGAR Be Noticed Eye Shimmer Putty Powder
      $23.00
      Free shipping at $75
      Free Shipping & Returns with $75 Beauty Purchase
      Free shipping at $75 Free shipping at $75
      Bonus Offer with Purchase
      Tarte Prom Set $12 w/ select Prom purchases
      Bonus Offer with Purchase Bonus Offer with Purchase
    • 4 colors
      bareMinerals Gen Nude® Eyeshadow Palette
      $29.00
      Free shipping at $75
      Free Shipping & Returns with $75 Beauty Purchase
      Free shipping at $75 Free shipping at $75
      Free gift with purchase
      Free Makeup Gift w/ $45 Select Beauty Purchase
      Free gift with purchase Free gift with purchase
      (88)
    • 8 colors
      bareMinerals Gen Nude® Cream Eyeshadow + Primer
      $20.00
      Free shipping at $75
      Free Shipping & Returns with $75 Beauty Purchase
      Free shipping at $75 Free shipping at $75
      Free gift with purchase
      Free Makeup Gift w/ $45 Select Beauty Purchase
      Free gift with purchase Free gift with purchase
      (62)
    • 2 colors
      Beauty by POPSUGAR Trio Time Eye Compact
      $27.00
      Free shipping at $75
      Free Shipping & Returns with $75 Beauty Purchase
      Free shipping at $75 Free shipping at $75
      Bonus Offer with Purchase
      Tarte Prom Set $12 w/ select Prom purchases
      Bonus Offer with Purchase Bonus Offer with Purchase
    • Tarte Tartelette Tools Beauty 101 Palette, Created for Macy's
      A $61.00 value
      Only $24.00
      Free shipping at $75
      Free Shipping & Returns with $75 Beauty Purchase
      Free shipping at $75 Free shipping at $75
      Free gift with purchase
      Free Makeup Gift w/ $45 Select Beauty Purchase
      Free gift with purchase Free gift with purchase
      (4)
    • Tarte Clay Play Face Shaping Palette
      $45.00
      Free shipping at $75
      Free Shipping & Returns with $75 Beauty Purchase
      Free shipping at $75 Free shipping at $75
      Free gift with purchase
      Free Makeup Gift w/ $45 Select Beauty Purchase
      Free gift with purchase Free gift with purchase
      (17)
    • Tarte Tartelette Toasted Eyeshadow Palette
      $39.00
      Free shipping at $75
      Free Shipping & Returns with $75 Beauty Purchase
      Free shipping at $75 Free shipping at $75
      Free gift with purchase
      Free Makeup Gift w/ $45 Select Beauty Purchase
      Free gift with purchase Free gift with purchase
      (21)
    • 2 colors
      Beauty by POPSUGAR Eyeshadow Palette
      $42.00
      Free shipping at $75
      Free Shipping & Returns with $75 Beauty Purchase
      Free shipping at $75 Free shipping at $75
      Bonus Offer with Purchase
      Tarte Prom Set $12 w/ select Prom purchases
      Bonus Offer with Purchase Bonus Offer with Purchase
      (1)
    • Tarte Tarteist™ PRO Palette
      $49.00
      Free shipping at $75
      Free Shipping & Returns with $75 Beauty Purchase
      Free shipping at $75 Free shipping at $75
      Free gift with purchase
      Free Makeup Gift w/ $45 Select Beauty Purchase
      Free gift with purchase Free gift with purchase
      (83)
    • 2 colors
      Beauty by POPSUGAR Crystal Power Palette
      $37.00
      Free shipping at $75
      Free Shipping & Returns with $75 Beauty Purchase
      Free shipping at $75 Free shipping at $75
      Bonus Offer with Purchase
      Tarte Prom Set $12 w/ select Prom purchases
      Bonus Offer with Purchase Bonus Offer with Purchase
    • 17 colors
      bareMinerals Glimmer Eyecolor
      $15.00
      Free shipping at $75
      Free Shipping & Returns with $75 Beauty Purchase
      Free shipping at $75 Free shipping at $75
      Free gift with purchase
      Free Makeup Gift w/ $45 Select Beauty Purchase
      Free gift with purchase Free gift with purchase
      (271)
    • Tarte Tartelette Amazonian Clay Matte Eyeshadow Palette
      $39.00
      Free shipping at $75
      Free Shipping & Returns with $75 Beauty Purchase
      Free shipping at $75 Free shipping at $75
      Free gift with purchase
      Free Makeup Gift w/ $45 Select Beauty Purchase
      Free gift with purchase Free gift with purchase
      (91)
    • Tarte 2-Pc. Turn Up The Glam Set
      A $54.00 value
      Only $38.00
      Free shipping at $75
      Free Shipping & Returns with $75 Beauty Purchase
      Free shipping at $75 Free shipping at $75
      Free gift with purchase
      Free Makeup Gift w/ $45 Select Beauty Purchase
      Free gift with purchase Free gift with purchase
      (2)
    • Tarte Tartelette Flirt Palette
      $19.00
      Free shipping at $75
      Free Shipping & Returns with $75 Beauty Purchase
      Free shipping at $75 Free shipping at $75
      Free gift with purchase
      Free Makeup Gift w/ $45 Select Beauty Purchase
      Free gift with purchase Free gift with purchase
      (2)
    • 3 colors
      NUDESTIX Nudies Matte Bronze
      $32.00
      Free shipping at $75
      Free Shipping & Returns with $75 Beauty Purchase
      Free shipping at $75 Free shipping at $75
      Free gift with purchase
      Free Makeup Gift w/ $45 Select Beauty Purchase
      Free gift with purchase Free gift with purchase
      (8)
    • 8 colors
      Tarte Chrome Paint Shadow Pot
      $22.00
      Free shipping at $75
      Free Shipping & Returns with $75 Beauty Purchase
      Free shipping at $75 Free shipping at $75
      Free gift with purchase
      Free Makeup Gift w/ $45 Select Beauty Purchase
      Free gift with purchase Free gift with purchase
      (4)
    • 6 colors
      bareMinerals Glimpse Eyecolor
      $15.00
      Free shipping at $75
      Free Shipping & Returns with $75 Beauty Purchase
      Free shipping at $75 Free shipping at $75
      Free gift with purchase
      Free Makeup Gift w/ $45 Select Beauty Purchase
      Free gift with purchase Free gift with purchase
      (141)
    • 6 colors
      Beauty by POPSUGAR Make Waves Liquid Metallic Eyeshadow
      $23.00
      Free shipping at $75
      Free Shipping & Returns with $75 Beauty Purchase
      Free shipping at $75 Free shipping at $75
      Bonus Offer with Purchase
      Tarte Prom Set $12 w/ select Prom purchases
      Bonus Offer with Purchase Bonus Offer with Purchase